Whether fans like it or not, the reality is clear—Manchester United is struggling in goal. André Onana’s performances have been a major concern, leaving supporters frustrated with his lack of presence, confidence, and shot-stopping ability. Week after week, the same issues persist, making many question if the club truly has a dependable goalkeeper.
Dimitar Berbatov, a former United striker, has now added his voice to the growing criticism. He didn’t hold back in a recent interview, echoing the sentiments of many fans who believe Onana is not the solution. According to Berbatov, a club of United’s stature needs a goalkeeper they can rely on in tough moments, someone who can step up when the defense falters. He even referenced the days of David de Gea, when the Spanish shot-stopper would pull off crucial saves to keep the team in matches. Instead, with Onana, mistakes keep piling up, costing the team valuable points.
Supporters have taken to social media, with some even calling for De Gea’s return following his resurgence at Fiorentina. The debate over Onana’s suitability is intensifying, and the statistics don’t do him any favors. Since arriving at Old Trafford in a £47.2 million move from Inter Milan, the numbers paint a bleak picture—most goals conceded among the Premier League’s top six, only six clean sheets in 28 league matches, and a save percentage below 65%, ranking among the lowest in the division. His inability to command the penalty area, questionable decision-making, and costly errors have made him more of a liability than an asset.
Of course, some argue that United’s defensive woes are not entirely Onana’s fault. Injuries, inconsistency, and disorganization at the back have all contributed to the team’s struggles. However, elite goalkeepers rise to the occasion even when the defense is shaky. De Gea did it for years, making world-class saves to bail United out of trouble. Onana, on the other hand, has repeatedly failed to deliver in those crucial moments, often caught out of position, slow to react, or unable to stop shots that a top goalkeeper should handle.
With United aiming to reclaim their spot among Europe’s elite, addressing their goalkeeping situation must be a priority. Reports suggest the club is already scouting potential replacements, with names like Jan Oblak, Diogo Costa, and Mike Maignan emerging as possible targets. Some supporters continue to push for a shocking De Gea return, believing he could still offer more stability than Onana.
As the summer transfer window approaches, the question looms large—should United cut their losses and part ways with Onana, or should he be given another season to prove himself? The pressure is mounting, and fans are running out of patience. If the club is serious about competing at the highest level, they cannot afford another season of goalkeeping uncertainty.
