Thierry Henry revealed the one transfer mistake Ruben Amorim made last summer that could come back to haunt him this season
Thierry Henry has sparked major controversy after brutally dismissing Benjamin Šeško’s value to Manchester United, calling the Slovenian striker “a waste of money.” The Arsenal legend made the blunt remark live on television following United’s most recent Premier League game, where Šeško once again struggled to make an impact under manager Ruben Amorim.
Henry didn’t hold back, saying he was shocked after watching Šeško play and insisting that Manchester United made a serious mistake by signing him. His words quickly went viral, with fans divided over whether he was being brutally honest or unnecessarily harsh.
The young striker joined United from RB Leipzig last summer for a reported £55 million, a move that was initially seen as a major coup for Amorim’s new era. He was expected to bring both physical strength and technical skill to United’s attack, but the transition to the Premier League has not gone smoothly. Šeško has looked off the pace, often struggling with his first touch, awareness, and confidence in front of goal — areas Henry was quick to highlight.
“He just looks lost,” Henry said. “There’s no hunger or confidence. For a striker wearing the Manchester United shirt, that’s simply not acceptable.”
As expected, opinions among supporters are split. Some fans agree with Henry, saying Šeško hasn’t justified his transfer fee, while others believe it’s unfair to write off such a young player who’s still adapting to English football.
The criticism couldn’t have come at a worse time for Ruben Amorim, whose side has been inconsistent despite showing flashes of potential. The manager has repeatedly defended Šeško, praising his attitude and commitment in training, but the lack of results on the pitch is becoming a growing concern inside Old Trafford.
Sources close to the team suggest Amorim is frustrated with the striker’s slow progress, and the coaching staff has been working privately to improve his off-ball movement and finishing. Yet, results have been mixed, and Šeško’s visible frustration during matches hasn’t gone unnoticed.
Henry’s comments carry extra weight because of his reputation for speaking the truth, no matter how uncomfortable it may be. Over the years, he’s criticized players like Lukaku and Sancho for failing to meet expectations, but this time he went a step further — suggesting that United’s entire decision to sign Šeško was flawed.
“Manchester United needed a proven finisher, not another project,” Henry explained. “When you’re fighting for titles against City, Arsenal, and Liverpool, you can’t afford to wait for potential to develop.”
Interestingly, even some former United players have partially agreed with Henry’s sentiment. Rio Ferdinand admitted that while Henry’s tone was harsh, there’s truth to the claim that Šeško still looks out of place. “The potential is there,” Ferdinand said, “but potential doesn’t win games — goals do.”
The pressure is now squarely on Šeško’s shoulders. Many promising players have been criticized early in their Premier League careers only to bounce back — but that depends on how he responds. Amorim is reportedly planning to give him one more chance in the next match, hoping he can finally deliver and justify his hefty price tag.
For United fans, patience is wearing thin. On social media, some supporters have called for the striker to step up or make way for someone else, while others urge faith, believing one good game could change everything.
Still, Thierry Henry’s brutal assessment has left a mark. Whether Šeško proves him wrong or confirms his doubts will likely define not just his future at Manchester United, but also Amorim’s credibility as a talent spotter.
For now, Henry’s words hang heavy over Old Trafford — a reminder that in football, reputation means nothing without results.
