Rio Ferdinand have criticized a Manchester United star after his nightmare display against Nottingham Forest, urging Amorim to take immediate action to rectify the situation

Manchester United suffered a frustrating 3-2 defeat against Nottingham Forest at Old Trafford, a result that exposed significant flaws both in individual performances and team cohesion. Despite flashes of brilliance from players like Bruno Fernandes and Rasmus Højlund, defensive errors and inconsistency ultimately decided the outcome.

Andre Onana endured a disastrous evening, delivering what was arguably his poorest performance since joining the club. The goalkeeper was at fault for two of Nottingham Forest’s goals, including a tame shot from Morgan Gibbs-White that inexplicably slipped through his grasp. His hesitation and lack of reaction for Chris Wood’s header further highlighted his struggles, leaving fans questioning his reliability.

In defense, Leny Yoro’s debut was a mix of promise and naivety. While he displayed clean passing and solid positioning, his failure to close down Wood for Forest’s third goal exposed his inexperience. Matthijs de Ligt showed his quality in the buildup to United’s first goal but lacked defensive sharpness, almost gifting Jota Silva a chance with a poor clearance. Lisandro Martinez also had a game to forget, losing a crucial aerial duel for Forest’s opener and sharing responsibility for Wood’s decisive goal.

The midfield saw mixed performances. Amad Diallo stood out as a rare bright spot, delivering a mesmerizing assist for Bruno Fernandes and injecting much-needed creativity into the attack. However, Kobbie Mainoo had an off day, offering little control or spark in midfield. Manuel Ugarte started strongly, playing a key role in Højlund’s equalizer, but his influence faded as the game progressed.

Among the fullbacks, Diogo Dalot delivered a steady, if unspectacular, performance, with some promising crosses that went unconverted. Alejandro Garnacho struggled to make an impact and was substituted early after a subdued display.

In attack, Bruno Fernandes was United’s best player. His clever assist for Højlund, a stunning goal of his own, and a near miss with a free kick showcased his quality, though a misplaced pass that led to Forest’s second goal blemished his overall contribution. Højlund impressed again with his sharp finishing and consistent threat, cementing his role as a key player in United’s frontline.

Substitutes offered little to change the game’s trajectory. Marcus Rashford and Noussair Mazraoui provided attacking support but failed to deliver decisive moments. Harry Maguire brought stability to the defense without being significantly tested, while Joshua Zirkzee and Mason Mount were largely ineffective after coming on.

This defeat underscores Manchester United’s ongoing issues, particularly in defense. Andre Onana and Lisandro Martinez were pivotal in the team’s undoing, overshadowing the creative efforts of players like Fernandes and Diallo. The result raises serious concerns about United’s defensive organization and overall mentality as they navigate a challenging start to the season.