A Furious Pundit Has Absolutely TORN INTO One Manchester United Player, Branding Him The Club’s Biggest Problem
Roy Keane has never been one to stay quiet when Manchester United fall short, and following another error-ridden display, the former captain has delivered one of his most unforgiving assessments yet. This time, his criticism was aimed squarely at Casemiro, a player Keane believes has become a major barrier to the club’s progress.
Reacting to United’s latest outing, Keane reportedly showed little restraint as he tore into the Brazilian midfielder, arguing that his time in the squad should come to an end immediately. In Keane’s view, the drop in Casemiro’s performances has gone on for too long, and the margin for patience has completely disappeared.
For a footballer who arrived at Old Trafford with the aura of an elite winner and one of Europe’s most reliable midfield enforcers, the contrast with his current form is striking. Casemiro was once hailed as the experienced presence United had been crying out for, but Keane feels that version of the player no longer exists. According to him, the club is suffering because it refuses to confront that reality.
Keane’s assessment was direct and unsparing. He pointed out that the same mistakes continue to surface every week, insisting that recent matches offer clear proof that nothing is improving. From his perspective, Casemiro is repeatedly involved in moments that destabilise the team, disrupt their shape, and strip them of control during key phases of games.
He also suggested that those making decisions at the club are turning a blind eye to what is obvious on the pitch. Keane warned that persisting with the midfielder is only deepening United’s problems and exposing them to further setbacks.
One comment in particular struck a chord with supporters, as Keane claimed that “football has left him.” For many fans, that line summed up the growing belief that Casemiro’s sharpness, mobility, and timing have declined too far to be recovered at the highest level. What was once a pillar of strength in United’s midfield now looks like a weakness that opponents are eager to target.
Casemiro’s decline has been uncomfortable to witness. When he joined from Real Madrid, he brought leadership, discipline, and a winning mentality that had an immediate impact. His reading of the game and ability to shield the defence were central to United’s midfield stability during his early spell at the club.
Recently, however, his performances have raised serious concerns. Against energetic and high-tempo opposition, he has often struggled to keep up, frequently being caught out during quick transitions and leaving space behind him.
Keane’s words carry added authority because of his own legacy. As one of the Premier League’s finest defensive midfielders, his understanding of the role is shaped by years of elite-level experience. When he speaks about positioning, standards, and responsibility, it comes from lived knowledge rather than abstract analysis.
His frustration reflects a wider belief that Manchester United are drifting away from their identity by tolerating decline instead of enforcing high standards. References to previous games, including the encounter with Wolves, underline his view that this is not a one-off slump but a worrying trend.
Time and again, United’s midfield has been overrun, and the player once trusted to offer protection has become a liability. Supporters have grown increasingly aware of the lack of mobility, slow reactions, and misplaced passes that invite unnecessary pressure.
For Ruben Amorim, the situation presents a clear test of leadership. Continuing to rely on Casemiro risks further criticism and dropped points, while leaving out a senior figure demands firmness and conviction. Keane’s message leaves little room for ambiguity: reputation and loyalty should never outweigh standards. How United respond to that challenge could shape the direction of their season.
