Bruno Fernandes, Manchester United’s captain, is facing a rare struggle from the penalty spot this season after missing two of his three Premier League attempts. Known for years as one of the most reliable finishers from twelve yards, his sudden dip has raised eyebrows and sparked debate among fans and pundits.
The Portuguese midfielder built his reputation on a distinctive penalty style — the quick hop and strike — which often caught goalkeepers off guard and made him nearly unstoppable since his arrival at Old Trafford in 2020. His conversion rate was so impressive that he was considered almost automatic, turning penalties into an important source of goals, especially in matches where United found it difficult to break down opponents.
But this season has told a different story. Two missed penalties out of three has left questions about whether Fernandes should remain the designated taker. Alternatives such as Marcus Rashford or new signing Rasmus Højlund are now being suggested, with the pressure mounting on Erik ten Hag to make a decision. The concern grows because Fernandes’s misses have come in decisive moments, depriving United of much-needed goals and momentum.
Confidence seems to be the bigger issue rather than technique. Even the greatest names — Cristiano Ronaldo, Lionel Messi, Harry Kane — have all endured rough patches from the spot, and Fernandes now finds himself in similar territory. What remains to be seen is how quickly he can shake off the doubts, regain his composure, and re-establish himself as the dependable figure he once was.
Among supporters, opinions are split. Many believe the captain deserves patience and trust given his overall influence and past record, while others argue it might be best to ease the pressure by handing penalty duties to someone else for the time being.
The next penalty Manchester United wins will carry extra weight, not just for the scoreboard but for Fernandes’s reputation. Whether he steps forward or watches another teammate take on the responsibility could have a major influence on both his confidence and United’s season.
