Diogo Dalot is not a wingback and the sooner Ruben Amorim understands this, the better for Man United
Manchester United showed resilience in their dramatic second-half comeback against Everton, securing a hard-fought draw at Goodison Park. However, while the result demonstrated their fighting spirit, it also highlighted tactical flaws—especially on the right flank, where Everton repeatedly found joy.
From the first whistle, Everton displayed greater intensity, winning duels and asserting dominance. In contrast, United looked disjointed, lacking urgency and control. Ruben Amorim, visibly frustrated on the sidelines, saw his side struggle to impose themselves in the first half. One of the most glaring issues was Diogo Dalot’s performance in the wingback role—a position that continues to expose his limitations. Amorim must recognize that persisting with Dalot in this system is doing more harm than good.
Initially deployed on the left earlier in the season, Dalot’s struggles were attributed to playing out of position. However, even after shifting back to his preferred right flank, his performances remain inconsistent. His decision-making let him down again, particularly in the lead-up to Everton’s opening goal. Instead of clearing a dangerous ball, he attempted to control it, leading to a defensive scramble that Beto ruthlessly punished. Such lapses are becoming all too frequent and raise serious concerns about his suitability in this setup.
Going forward, Dalot offered little. As a wingback, he is expected to provide attacking width, yet he failed to deliver a single cross throughout the match. In comparison, Patrick Dorgu on the opposite side attempted four. Dalot’s approach remained conservative, often opting for safe back-passes rather than taking on his marker. His 91% pass completion rate may look impressive on paper, but with zero crosses, dribbles, or shots, it paints a picture of a player struggling to meet the demands of the role.
Amorim’s system relies on wingbacks who can push high, stretch the opposition, and contribute offensively. Dalot does not fit that profile. While he may be a capable traditional full-back, he lacks the attacking output and defensive solidity required in this position. If Manchester United are serious about competing at the highest level, they must address this issue urgently.
This debate around Dalot has persisted for some time—his cautious play and defensive vulnerabilities continue to hinder United. Amorim faces a critical decision: does he persist with Dalot due to a lack of alternatives, or does he push for reinforcements? If the current system is here to stay, then a specialist right wingback is a necessity. Otherwise, adjustments may be needed to accommodate the players at his disposal.
